Quick answer
Spike is an incident management tool that works out of the box, with no add-ons to buy. It takes alerts from your monitoring tools and reaches the right person by phone, SMS, Slack, or Teams until someone responds. PagerDuty is an operations platform for on-call, incident response, AIOps, automation, and AI agents. It’s a platform you configure, so as your needs grow you buy add-ons and set up more of it.
Pick Spike if you want team-level and individual control over alerts, with grouping, AI, a status page, and live call routing in the plan price. That holds for one team and for a larger company that needs SSO, roles, and audit logs under one yearly quote. Pick PagerDuty if you need deep ServiceNow workflows, a large set of integrations, machine-learning event orchestration, or an AI agent that runs fixes. Its add-ons and platform plans are priced separately, so the full cost is worth checking early.
Choosing the tool that decides who gets the 3am phone call is a big decision. Here’s how PagerDuty and Spike compare, feature by feature.
I work at Spike, so I have a stake in which one you pick. Even so, I tested both tools thoroughly and tried my best to give you a fair comparison. PagerDuty’s plans and limits come from its pricing page, and anything I couldn’t confirm is left out. Prices were checked on 12 November 2026.
PagerDuty vs Spike at a glance
| PagerDuty | Spike | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An operations platform for on-call and incident response. AIOps, automation, and AI agents are sold as add-ons or in yearly platform plans | An incident management and on-call tool. It routes alerts from your monitoring tools to whoever is on call, with status pages and AI in every plan |
| Plans and starting price | Free. Professional $25 per user a month, or $21 billed yearly. Platform plans from $2,800 a year | Standard $7 and Business $14 per user a month, or $6.40 and $12.80 billed yearly. Enterprise is quoted |
| Free plan | Yes, up to 5 users | No. 14-day free trial |
| Phone and SMS alerts | Included on Professional. 100 a month on Free | 100 a month across the team on Standard. Unlimited on Business |
| Alert channel per escalation level | No. Each person sets their own | Yes, on every plan. People can add their own rules too |
| Noise reduction | Grouping and suppression need AIOps on Professional | Grouping and suppression on every plan |
| On-call scheduling | Yes. Round robin from Starter | Yes. 1 schedule on Standard, unlimited on Business |
| Live call routing | Add-on on Professional | 5 calls a month on Standard, unlimited on Business |
| Status pages | 1 public page with 250 subscribers on Professional | On every plan. Private pages on Business |
| Slack and Teams | Yes | Yes |
| Post-incident reviews | Yes, from Professional | Notes and an activity log per incident |
| AI | With PagerDuty Advance or a platform plan | On every plan, no credits |
| SSO, roles, and audit logs | SSO and roles from Professional. Audit trail from Starter, a platform plan | Roles and multiple teams on Business. SAML SSO and audit logs on Enterprise |
| Integrations | 750+ | 180+ |
| API, Terraform, and MCP server | Yes. MCP server from Professional | Yes. MCP server on every plan |
The core difference: a platform you configure vs a tool that works out of the box
In PagerDuty, the basics are easy to set up. Connecting a monitoring tool, building a rotation, and writing an escalation policy all went smoothly in my tests.
“Platform you configure” is about what comes after that. Each time your team needs more than alerts and a rotation, there’s often something to buy and set up. Here’s what that looks like on Professional, from PagerDuty’s pricing page:
- Cutting alert noise with machine learning needs the AIOps add-on.
- Generative AI features like AI-written review drafts need PagerDuty Advance.
- The Paige, Shift, Scribe, and Insights agents are each their own add-on.
- Scripted fixes need Runbook Automation.
- A status page with more than 250 subscribers needs the Status Pages add-on.
- One phone number that reaches whoever is on call needs Live Call Routing.
None of these add-ons has a published price. Above Professional, PagerDuty sells yearly platform plans with a set number of seats, events, and AI actions. Essential, Plus, and Ultimate also require PagerDuty’s Expert Services. That service has no published price either. Our PagerDuty pricing breakdown covers every plan.
In Spike, the same needs are part of the plan you’re on. Alert grouping, AI, a status page, and live call routing come with Standard and Business. There are no add-ons to buy and no services to hire. You connect a monitoring tool with a webhook URL and can have your first rotation live the same day.
“Spike works out of the box, so I can do most of the stuff myself and fine-tune it to how we work.”
Matic Bončina, Founder, Noxity
Alerting and escalations
I tested escalation policies in both tools. In PagerDuty, each escalation level sets who gets alerted and after how many minutes. The alert channel is each person’s own setting, so a team lead can’t make level 1 a phone call.
Spike gives you control at both levels. The team sets the channel for each escalation level, so level 1 can be a phone call and level 2 a Slack message to the team lead. Each person can then add their own rules on top, like SMS outside office hours or forwarding alerts while they’re away.

Both tools repeat an escalation if nobody responds. Both reach your phone through Do Not Disturb. In Spike, it works through a contact card saved to your favourites and critical alerts in the mobile app.
Noise reduction is where the plans differ. PagerDuty’s pricing page lists alert grouping and suppression under AIOps on Professional. Spike groups repeats of the same alert into one incident and suppresses alerts on every plan.
Spike’s alert rules go a step further. Each rule is an if-then check on every incoming alert. If the title contains “payments”, the alert can go to the payments team’s escalation policy. If an alert repeats five times within ten minutes, its priority can go up. Rules can also ignore alerts nobody needs to see, or send phone calls at night and Slack messages by day. Standard includes 1 alert rule, and Business has unlimited rules.
“With Spike, we’ve gained more control over how we manage incidents. We can focus on what matters most, without being distracted by minor alerts.”
Mohammad Hani, Head of Engineering, Thndr
Live call routing gives callers one number that rings whoever is on call. It’s an add-on on PagerDuty Professional. Spike includes 5 incoming calls a month on Standard and unlimited calls on Business.
On-call scheduling
Both tools handle layered rotations, overrides, and shift notifications well. PagerDuty’s newer schedules have quick-start templates, and round robin scheduling comes with Starter and up. Its Shift Agent finds on-call conflicts and arranges cover from Slack. On Professional, it’s a paid add-on.
Spike includes these on every plan:
- overrides with an optional comment, from the dashboard or Slack
- out of office, which forwards your alerts to a teammate
- alert routing by office hours
- shift start and end messages to Slack, Teams, or Discord
- calendar sync for your own shifts, one schedule, or the whole team
Recent updates made Spike’s schedules more flexible:
- gaps in a rotation, where the next layer steps in
- layers with start and end dates, so holiday cover switches on and off by itself
- a handoff day you choose, like every Monday
- layer templates for weekdays, weekends, night shifts, and business hours
- holiday and other external calendars shown on the on-call calendar
- out of office that admins can set for anyone, with time off visible to the whole team

“It has made planning our on-call shifts much easier, and handing over a shift to a colleague works really smoothly as well.”
Joost Golstein, ICT Manager & Security Officer, Perplex Digital
Incident response in Slack and Teams
PagerDuty Professional includes Slack and Teams actions. It can also create a Slack channel per incident, open Jira tickets, and add conference links. Incident priority, extra responders mid-incident, and custom fields come with Starter and up.
Spike’s Slack app lets responders acknowledge, resolve, add notes, override shifts, and ask AI about an incident without leaving Slack. A Teams bot comes with every plan too. War rooms and Jira, Linear, and ClickUp tickets are on Business. Jira also syncs both ways.
Post-incident reviews
PagerDuty has a dedicated post-incident review feature on Professional. It comes with a custom template, a timeline builder, and follow-up actions. AI-written review drafts need PagerDuty Advance.
Spike takes a lighter approach. Each incident keeps its notes, resolution notes with edit history, and an activity log of who was alerted and when. On Business, notes and status sync both ways with Jira. Webhooks can also send the incident record to the docs tool your team already writes reviews in.
AI: PagerDuty vs Spike
PagerDuty goes further here. Its Paige agent can diagnose incidents and run fixes with your approval. That depth comes at a cost. On Professional, Paige is a paid add-on with no published price. Platform plans include it with a set number of AI actions, from $2,800 a year for Starter. Teams that use more actions buy credit packs.
Spike’s AI works out of the box, with no credits to buy. It writes incident titles, suggests severity and priority, and answers questions about any incident.
Status pages
PagerDuty Professional includes one public status page with up to 250 subscribers. More subscribers and audience-specific pages come with the Status Pages add-on. Private pages start on Starter.
Spike includes a status page on every plan, with your branding, an embeddable widget, and subscriptions. Private pages and subscriber management are on Business.

Integrations, monitoring tools, and API
PagerDuty lists 750+ integrations. Spike has 180+, and each one is a webhook URL. If a tool is missing, we build it within 72 hours.
The common monitoring tools work with both. Datadog, Prometheus, Grafana, New Relic, and Sentry all have Spike integration guides.
Both tools have an API, a Terraform provider, and an MCP server. You can keep schedules and escalation policies in code or connect your own AI tools. PagerDuty’s MCP server comes with Professional and up. Spike’s is on every plan.
PagerDuty vs Spike pricing
PagerDuty Professional and Spike both charge per user. Here’s what list prices come to for 10 and 25 responders:
| Monthly cost | 10 responders | 25 responders |
|---|---|---|
| PagerDuty Professional, billed monthly | $250 | $625 |
| PagerDuty Professional, billed yearly | $210 | $525 |
| Spike Standard, billed monthly | $70 | $175 |
| Spike Standard, billed yearly | $64 | $160 |
| Spike Business, billed monthly | $140 | $350 |
| Spike Business, billed yearly | $128 | $320 |
These are list prices only. PagerDuty doesn’t publish prices for its add-ons, so the real bill grows with each one you add. Spike Standard’s phone and SMS alerts are capped, so Business is the closer match to PagerDuty Professional.
Our PagerDuty alternative page has a calculator for other team sizes.
Larger companies usually buy on yearly terms. PagerDuty’s platform plans start at $2,800 a year for Starter. Spike Enterprise is one yearly quote with nothing metered. Our guide to PagerDuty alternatives for enterprise teams compares what each enterprise plan includes.
Access control, security, and support for larger teams
Larger teams also need control over who signs in, what each person can change, and a record of every change. Both tools cover this on different plans.
| PagerDuty | Spike | |
|---|---|---|
| Single sign-on | From Professional | SAML SSO on Enterprise. Admins can make it the only way in |
| Roles and permissions | Role-based permissions on every plan | Admin, manager, responder, and viewer roles plus custom roles, on Business |
| Teams | 2 on Professional. More on platform plans | Multiple teams on Business, each with its own schedules and escalation policies |
| Audit logs | Audit trail from Starter, a platform plan | On Enterprise, filterable by person, item, and action |
| Incident history | 1 year on Professional | 3 years on Enterprise |
| Support | Email and chat. Gold Services is an add-on | 24/7 help in a private Slack channel on Enterprise |
Spike is GDPR compliant and signs your DPA. All data is encrypted at rest with AES-256, and our team fills in your security questionnaire. Data is stored in the US East region.
What Spike doesn’t do
Here’s what PagerDuty offers that Spike doesn’t. Our PagerDuty review covers its strengths in more detail.
| Need | PagerDuty | Spike |
|---|---|---|
| ServiceNow integration | Yes. Two-way field sync on Plus and Ultimate | No |
| Machine-learning noise reduction and event orchestration | Yes, with AIOps | Grouping and suppression rules |
| An AI agent that runs fixes | Paige, with approval | No |
| Service dependency maps | Yes | No |
Post-incident reviews and integration count are covered in their own sections above.
Moving from PagerDuty to Spike
You can set it up yourself, or let us do it for you. Doing it yourself works through the dashboard, the Terraform provider, the API, or the MCP server. Or our team moves your schedules and escalation policies for you. On Enterprise, we rebuild your setup and move it team by team before your PagerDuty renewal.
Running both tools side by side for a full on-call rotation usually works best. Here’s a short way to test them against each other:
- one test alert sent to both tools
- the first alert left unanswered, to see who gets the next one and how
- a rotation with a day-off override
- an update on each status page, to see what subscribers receive
- a count of everyone who needs on-call access, to price both tools
PagerDuty or Spike?
PagerDuty gives you a platform to configure and buy into, piece by piece. Spike gives you alerting, escalations, on-call, status pages, and AI that work from the first day for one team or many. If you use the pieces PagerDuty adds, it earns its price. If you don’t, Spike is worth a closer look.
FAQ
Is Spike just a cheaper PagerDuty?
No. Spike covers the alerting, on-call, and escalation work PagerDuty is known for. Its lower price comes from including AI, status pages, and live call routing in each plan instead of selling them separately. It also does one thing PagerDuty doesn’t. The team sets the alert channel for each escalation level, and each person can add their own rules on top.
Is Spike only for small teams?
No. Spike works for a five-person startup and for a company with a separate team for every service. What changes as a company grows is the need for control and support. Larger customers use SAML SSO, custom roles, and audit logs. Our team also moves them off PagerDuty one team at a time. Our PagerDuty alternative for enterprise page covers how that works.
Does Spike have a free plan?
No. Spike has a 14-day free trial on Standard and Business. PagerDuty has a Free plan for up to 5 users with one schedule and one escalation policy.
Is Spike a good PagerDuty alternative for a 25-person team?
Yes, if your team needs alerting, escalations, on-call, and a status page more than ServiceNow or AIOps. On Spike Business, 25 people cost $350 a month or $320 billed yearly. That plan includes unlimited phone and SMS alerts, multiple teams, and two-way Jira sync.
Does Spike integrate with ServiceNow?
No. On Business, Spike creates Jira, Linear, and ClickUp tickets. Jira tickets also sync both ways. If ServiceNow is central to your incident process, PagerDuty is the better fit.
Who are PagerDuty’s main competitors?
Spike, incident.io, Rootly, and Jira Service Management are common picks. Spike starts at $7 per user a month, or $6.40 billed yearly. incident.io’s Team plan is $19 per user a month ($15 billed yearly), and on-call adds $10 per user. Rootly’s incident response and on-call products are $20 per user each. Jira Service Management is free for 3 agents, then $26.90 per agent on Standard at 10 agents. Our PagerDuty alternatives post compares more of them.
How long does it take to move from PagerDuty to Spike?
Your first rotation can be live the same day. The full move depends on how many schedules, escalation policies, and integrations you have. Running both tools until a full rotation has passed is the safe way to switch.